Birders and wildlife photographers can sometimes become frustrated or overzealous in their pursuit of elusive species. Driven by the desire to capture the perfect avian silhouette through binoculars or a camera lens, they may turn to a practice enabled by portable technology: playback. This involves playing a recording of a bird’s call to attract the bird (assuming it is within earshot).
Playback can be harmful, particularly when it involves predatory bird calls, which can panic smaller prey species, disrupting their foraging, nesting, and breeding behaviors. This effect is particularly harmful to endangered species. Additionally, excessive playback confuses birds and can lead to nest abandonment. Overuse also poses challenges for researchers, as it diminishes birds’ responsiveness to playback used for scientific purposes. For smaller bird species that are prey to larger ones, the playback of a predator’s call can induce panic. This fearful state may disrupt normal behaviors like eating, foraging, and breeding. In some cases, prey birds might neglect or even abandon their nests entirely—an outcome especially devastating for endangered or at-risk species struggling to survive.
This disruption can also hinder scientific research. Playback is sometimes used by researchers to band birds or retrieve geolocators for tracking their movements. However, overexposure to playback may cause certain species to stop responding, complicating conservation efforts. Jennifer Tyrell, a Master Bird Bander with Audubon South Carolina, explains, “Certain species will hear so much playback that they won’t respond when researchers attempt to capture them.” In the U.S., using bird recordings is prohibited in national parks and wildlife refuges, though regulations vary widely elsewhere.
For birders and wildlife photographers, adhering to park and preserve guidelines is crucial. When in doubt, check with local offices to determine whether playback is allowed. Even if permitted, consider the potential harm it may cause. Instead, use playback indoors to familiarize yourself with bird sounds before venturing into the field. This approach allows you to identify birds without causing disruptions. By educating fellow enthusiasts on the drawbacks of playback and leading by example, you can help protect the delicate balance of wildlife in natural habitats.
Matter referenced from:
Liv Konen. July 23, 2024. The Ethics of Playback: Using Recorded Birdsong to Attract Birds. https://emagazine.com/the-ethics-of-playback-using-recorded-birdsong-to-attract-birds/
By: Dr. Bhawana Asnani.
Happy to see Reviews, Additions, Suggestions and Comments, further.
